Natural disasters like hurricanes, floods, and wildfires are increasingly frequent, and their impacts on communities can be devastating. However, what happens after these events is a story many are unaware of how local, state, and federal agencies coordinate relief efforts, and why things don’t always move as fast as we’d like. In this post, we’ll dive into the intricacies of disaster response, drawing insights from a recent episode of the Second Chance Podcast featuring retired public safety veteran Billy Ferguson.

Billy, with 43 years of experience in emergency management, explains how disaster relief operates on multiple levels, from the local to federal stage, and sheds light on the often misunderstood delays and challenges. We’ll explore these concepts in detail, offering a guide on how communities can best prepare for and respond to disasters, and how individuals can contribute effectively.

The Anatomy of Disaster Response

When a disaster like Hurricane Helene strikes, the initial responsibility falls on local governments. These are the officials closest to the problem, and they are often the first to assess the damage and initiate emergency protocols. According to Billy Ferguson, disaster response starts with a local declaration of emergency, which may escalate to involve state and federal aid if the damage exceeds the local capacity to handle it.

Local and State Emergency Declarations

One of the most crucial steps in mobilizing resources is declaring an emergency at the local level. This allows local governments to access state resources and prepare for more extensive relief operations. For example, when Hurricane Helene hit Western North Carolina in September 2024, Governor Roy Cooper declared a state of emergency on September 25, enabling the deployment of National Guard units and swift-water rescue teams to help with the anticipated flood and landslide risks  .

A state emergency declaration also allows for the suspension of certain procurement laws, making it easier for governments to purchase emergency supplies without navigating lengthy bureaucratic processes. It’s all about speed, but even with this flexibility, there are limitations.

Federal Disaster Declarations: A Higher Level of Aid

The involvement of federal aid, such as FEMA (Federal Emergency Management Agency), only kicks in when a state requests help and the President approves a major disaster declaration. President Biden did just that on September 29, 2024, following Governor Cooper’s request for federal assistance . This declaration provided critical aid to the 25 hardest-hit counties, including Buncombe, Haywood, and Watauga, enabling affected residents to apply for FEMA’s Individual Assistance program and allowing the state to access funds for repairing infrastructure .

However, as Billy Ferguson explains, even with federal assistance, the process can be slow. FEMA aid requires detailed documentation of expenses, and reimbursements for costs like debris removal or shelter management can take months or even years to process.

The Challenges of Coordinated Relief

A key theme throughout the podcast episode is the complexity of managing disaster relief on a large scale. From coordinating donations to ensuring that volunteers are used effectively, relief operations are often hampered by well-meaning but misdirected efforts.

Why Donations and Volunteers Can Complicate Relief

While many people feel compelled to help during disasters, unsolicited donations and volunteers can overwhelm emergency management operations. According to Ferguson, unsolicited donations like truckloads of bottled water or clothing often create logistical problems. “Where do we store all of this? How do we distribute it?” he asks. In some cases, these goods can even end up being wasted if they can’t be distributed quickly enough .

Instead, Ferguson advises that cash donations to reputable organizations like the Red Cross or Samaritan’s Purse are the most effective way to help. These organizations already have supply chains in place and can purchase exactly what is needed on the ground. As for volunteers, while the desire to help is commendable, Ferguson stresses that volunteers should go through official channels, such as Voads (Voluntary Organizations Active in Disasters), which coordinate efforts to prevent overwhelming the local response teams.

Improving Emergency Communication

Communication is another critical factor that can make or break disaster response efforts. Ferguson mentions that poor communication between agencies or even with the public can delay aid. He points to the example of Hurricane Katrina, where the lack of timely communication between the local government and federal agencies resulted in significant delays in relief .

Local governments need to request help as soon as they realize their resources will be insufficient. However, sometimes pride or miscalculation delays this request, leading to unnecessary suffering. For example, if a local jurisdiction doesn’t declare an emergency promptly, state and federal aid can’t be mobilized.

The Long Road to Recovery

One of the most striking aspects of Ferguson’s discussion is the understanding that disaster recovery isn’t a short-term process. It can take years for communities to fully recover from a major event. Katrina, for instance, continues to have lingering effects nearly 20 years later. Roads and bridges that were wiped out by Hurricane Helene in Western North Carolina will take months, if not years, to rebuild .

This is why Ferguson advises patience. While it’s natural to want immediate results, the process of rebuilding infrastructure, restoring services, and ensuring public safety takes time and coordination. Emergency managers are not only tasked with dealing with the immediate aftermath but also planning for the long-term recovery.

How You Can Help During a Disaster

For those wondering how they can contribute during a disaster, here are some key takeaways from Billy Ferguson’s experience:

  • Donate Cash: The most effective way to help is by donating to established organizations that know how to distribute resources where they are needed most.
  • Volunteer Responsibly: If you want to volunteer, do so through official channels like Voads or local emergency management offices. Avoid showing up unannounced, as it could add to the logistical burden.
  • Prepare Locally: Ensure that you and your family are prepared for potential disasters. Have an emergency plan, stock up on necessary supplies, and stay informed through local news and emergency alerts.
  • Be Patient: Understand that recovery is a long process. While relief efforts are immediate, rebuilding takes time, and ongoing support will be needed long after the storm has passed.

Conclusion: A Call for Better Understanding

Disaster relief is a complicated process, with many moving parts. While the impulse to help is noble, understanding how relief operations work and what makes them successful can make a big difference. Billy Ferguson’s insights provide a valuable perspective on why some relief efforts seem slow and how we can better prepare as individuals and communities. By donating wisely, volunteering responsibly, and being patient, we can all contribute to a more effective response in the wake of disaster.

For more in-depth conversations like this, check out the full episode of the Second Chance Podcast and learn how you can be part of the solution during times of crisis.

Sources: